A federal judge weighing whether to approve a proposed settlement between merchants and the card networks Visa and Mastercard said the case will go to trial in 2027 if he decides not to give final approval to the accord.
U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan told the parties at the end of a Monday hearing on the proposal that he has not yet decided if he’ll give the settlement final approval. Cogan, who is overseeing the case in Brooklyn, New York, said at the end of the 90-minute hearing that he’ll issue a ruling as soon as possible.
The case pits merchants like convenience retail chain Circle K Stores, owned by Alimentation Couche-Tard, and DoorDash against the two networks, who they allege conspire with large banks to set default interchange rates in violation of U.S. antitrust law. Merchants must pay interchange and other fees whenever a consumer swipes a card to make a payment.
Earlier in the hearing, Cogan told the parties that he won’t do “any more head-banging to get a settlement if I reject this settlement,” which would set up a trial next year. A different judge rejected a prior settlement in June 2024, saying it didn’t treat large and small merchants equitably in some areas of the agreement.
In June, Cogan granted preliminary approval to the pact, which would conclude 21 years of litigation between a class of 12 million merchants that sued the two largest U.S. card networks and multiple large banks.
About 1,000 larger merchants and trade associations led by the mega retailer Walmart, the National Retail Federation and the National Association of Convenience Stores, have lodged settlement objections that Cogan is considering.
The settlement would trim credit interchange rates by 10 basis points for five years and impose a 1.25% rate for standard consumer cards for eight years. It would also give merchants the right to decline some higher-cost branded Visa and Mastercard premium and commercial credit cards. That would be a departure from the networks’ “honor all cards” rule requiring merchants to accept all cards from the networks if they accept any cards.
In 2024, merchants paid a 2.35% fee, on average, on card transactions routed over Visa and Mastercard networks, according to industry research organization Nilson Report in 2025. Card swipe fees totaled $198.3 billion last year, with Visa and Mastercard accounting for 60% of those, according to the Merchants Payments Coalition.
Merchants would also gain new rights to add surcharges and offer discounts for cards as a way to steer customers away from cards with higher interchange fees. But large merchants argue that they can’t easily reject the premium cards issued by banks – which offer consumers travel and cashback rewards and carry higher fees – because they are popular with customers.
Cogan’s decision is subject to appeal at the 2nd Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals in New York City.
As part of a brief discussion on litigation risk during the hearing, Cogan said the parties would have about two months to prepare for a trial, followed by a roughly two-month trial. If plaintiffs won, the parties would then offer their views of how the court might craft an injunction, further delaying a conclusion of the litigation, Cogan noted.
A trial process is extensive but “it’s not going to be as protracted as it has been, but still a protracted process, which is one thing I have to consider,” the judge said.
Cogan also oversees a related part of the litigation, a $5.5 billion settlement from the networks eight years ago that covers damages for merchants. To date, the settlement fund has paid about $631.7 million to about 689,000 merchants, according to a report last month from Epiq, the class administrator in the litigation.